JV and THE BIG CATS


Home

Mission

Founder: John Varty

Tiger Canyons
Tiger Experiment
Invest in Tigers
Tiger Canyons tigers

Tiger Anatomy

Tourism

Volunteers
Merchandise
Research
JV Image Library
JV's Music

JV's Films

Poaching

Tiger Conservation

Tiger Subspecies

Tiger Newsletters

Tiger Photo Gallery

Contact us


 

 


Select newsletter in right column


Newsletter 124
04/10/15

‎Bad Tigers


Corbett: Picture Keisha Kleinhans

"Is Ranthambore for me
Or is it for you
Why do hundreds of pilgrims
Come walking right on through"
- From the song Ustad

After Corbett killed Tiger Boy, several people have urged me to destroy Corbett, calling him a "bad cat."

So let's examine the facts, Corbett killed Tigress Shine. (Shine was the first white tigress born at Tiger Canyons and was in Julie's second litter which was abandoned.) At the time Corbett killed Shine, he was just 20 months old, he was not a dominant male. 

The hunters trying to steal Shine had shot her with a tranquilizing dart and she had run into heavy reeds. As Shine recovered from the drug, she would have thrashed around simulating a wounded or injured animal in distress. Corbett killed her and partially ate her (This is told in the book "In the Jaws of the Tiger".) 

When Corbett killed Tiger Boy, he was a dominant territorial male. A week previously Tiger Boy had killed a cub of which Corbett is the father. (Zaria is the mother and two cubs remain.) 

Instead of retreating to another area, Tiger Boy and his brother Shy Boy stayed inside Corbett's area. (Perhaps Tiger Boy thought that with his brother Shy Boy, the two of them could remove Corbett from his territory and kill the remaining cubs.) 

Unfortunately for Tiger Boy, Corbett caught him on his own and killed him. 

Neither the killing of Shine nor the killing of Tiger Boy is unnatural behaviour. By no stretch of the imagination can Corbett be labeled a "bad tiger."


Ustad: Picture Siva Baskaran

Ust‎ad the dominant tiger  of Ranthambore, who has attracted so much publicity, has entirely different circumstances. Ustad lives in Ranthambore where thousands of pilgrims walk through the park daily to a temple where they go to pray. 

Ustad is accused of killing 4 human beings over a period of 5 years. Recently a forest guard was killed and Ustad was seen nearby. He immediately became the number one suspect.  

Ustad's defenders say it cannot possibly be Ustad as they have pictures of Ustad strolling past women collecting water and he made no attack. 

This is not the point. If Ustad has made a large kill and he is not hungry, then he does not regard humans as potential prey. If Ustad has not been successful in hunting and he is hungry, then he may well regard a puny human who can't run as an easy meal. 

Does this make him a bad cat? Not at all! 

I blame the authorities. They must decide if Ranthambore is for people or is it for tigers. Hundreds of pilgrims, men, women and children are not compatible with tigers. Any tigers! 

Temples are man made structures, they can be placed outside the park. Ranthambore is a jewel gifted by Gaia and home to one of the last wild populations of tigers on earth. It cannot be replicated by human beings. 

I say, relocate the temple to outside the park, fence the park and commit it to tigers. 

Africa has many examples, where using electrical wire fences, large cats (lion, leopard and cheetah) are separated from domestic stock and people. India could easily copy the African example. They plead poverty, but truth be known, the government is bureaucratic and apathetic. By 2020 India will have the largest human population on planet earth. These people are competing for the same resources as the tiger.

So Ustad is removed to a zoo where he will disintegrate into depression and insanity. Another male tiger will take over Ustad's territory (probably has already taken the territory) and he too, lured by the chance of an easy meal, will kill an unwary forest guard or fatigued pilgrim walking through his territory.  

Another "bad cat" will then either be killed or moved to the zoo. 

Tread Lightly on the Earth
JV


Craig Packer: ‘Cecil the lion’s killer was unlucky and not altogether to blame’  

The ecologist and author has spent 30 years researching the overhunting of lions in Africa and is deeply pessimistic about their future. Here he talks about dishonest hunting operators, the urgent need for global money, why he takes issue with animal groups – and what we’ve learned from Cecil

John Vidal

Sunday 4 October 2015 07.59 BST  

Craig Packer likes sticking his shaggy academic head into dangerous places. He’s had death threats, confronted megalomaniac politicians, been run out of countries and mugged. But the man who has spent 30 years trying to study and save lions came close to real fear last month. 

As the world’s media worked themselves into a tizz over the American dentist who paid $50,000 to shoot Cecil the lion in Zimbabwe, Packer happened to have severe toothache, which forced him to seek treatment in Minneapolis, where he directs the Lion Research Centre at the university. 

“And what do you do?” asked the dentist, drill in hand. 

“Oh, I study lions…” 

There was an uncomfortable pause, Packer says. “Suddenly I felt very vulnerable. This is a class of people who can cause significant pain…” 

Packer got out alive, just as he did when invited to meet Steven Chancellor, the billionaire lion hunter and leading donor to the Bush 2004 presidential campaign. He had been seeking better regulation of trophy hunting in Tanzania and got a tour of the big game hunter’s mansion. One room had two large elephants, 10 leopards, six hyenas, and 15 dead lions. 

The tableau of death was chilling, he writes in his new book. “The lions are all busy… At least three pairs are working together to pull down various prey while a larger group is stalking an eland. It is like a workout room at a gym, but nothing moves… At the end of the tour I have seen at least 50 lions.” 

“As you can see, I have a special love of lions,” Chancellor told him. 

Packer bit his lip and left. “I was numb. When I see an animal, I want to know what it’s about to do next. They lead the most interesting lives. But no matter how lifelike Chancellor’s stuffed animals, they were all frozen in death. They had all been reduced to mere reflections of him.” 

After 30 years researching the overhunting of lions in Africa, Packer is profoundly pessimistic about their future. The figures are stark. The global population has dropped to under 30,000 from 100,000 in the 1980s; there are fewer than 2,000 left in Kenya, only 2,800 wild lions in South Africa, and numbers have declined 66% in 15 years in Tanzania. Yet hunters are invited to kill thousands every year and vast tracts are reserved for hunting.  

Their long-term survival, he says, depends on big money coming in to protect them. But counterintuitively, he says, trophy hunters like Chancellor or the dentist are also needed. 

“Trophy hunting is not inherently damaging to lion populations, provided the hunters take care to let the males mature and wait to harvest them after their cubs are safely reared. The dentist was unlucky and not altogether to blame. 

“Trophy hunters are no angels but they actually control four times as much lion habitat in Africa than is protected in national parks; and 80% of the world’s lions left in the world are in the hunters’ hands.” 

“Clients like the dentist are just tourists. They believe whatever they are told. It’s extremely unlikely that [the dentist] knew anything about that particular lion or even how close he was to the national park when he shot it. It’s common practice in Zimbabwe for hunting operators to draw lions out of the parks so their clients can shoot them.” 

However much he scorns the city slickers who spray bullets at anything with fangs, he insists he is not waging war on controlled hunting. 

The problem is the companies are under extreme pressure to provide big male lions for their clients, and the industry is sleazy and corrupt. Some professional hunters engage in double hunting, where they let their clients exceed the quota of lions they can kill and then bury the less impressive lion; others will shoot a buffalo before the client arrives to bait a site to attract a lion so it can be easily shot on day one. 

“If you are well connected you don’t even have to pay the government. Professional hunters are mostly working-class kids from South Africa, white Kenyans, French, Brits. These guys are pros but there is no oversight or accountability. 

“The corrupt companies all have connection with government. They are ruthless. The good ones fear that they will not be able to carry on if I name them. Hunting in Tanzania has been a bad thing. Kenya is just as bad.” 

The hunting industry argues that its money goes to conservation, but Packer rejects this. “Hunters lie and the industry greatly exaggerates its ‘positive’ impact on wildlife conservation,” he says. “A lot of clients head off into the bush believing that their $50,000 will save the world – when in fact virtually none of that money goes to conservation and the true costs of conservation are far higher. [With Cecil] the hunters paid a small fine to the Zimbabwean government, while the dentist became the international scapegoat.“[Yet] hunting could well provide the best possible incentive for conserving vast tracks of land. Lions occupy the top of the pyramid. If hunters take care of entire ecosystems – the land, the plants and the herbivores – they would be rewarded with healthy numbers of lions. 

“I get hunting. It’s done a lot for conservation in North America. Done well, it’s good for preserving wildlife and can be a valuable wildlife management tool. I grew up in Texas. I used to shoot ducks, rabbits, birds for the pot.” 

Packer – who first went to Tanzania to study baboons with [British primatologist] Jane Goodall, and whose field research on lion manes, the colouring of noses and overhunting has provided countries with the science to regulate lion conservation – has come to identify with the animals he researches. 

“Lions sit around doing nothing for long periods of time, then they get up and do the most amazing things, like catch a buffalo or chase off their neighbours. This seems like a life well-lived. I endure long periods of teaching, writing grants, dealing with bureaucrats, then I’ve had the good fortune to experience the most amazing things. 

“And like lions, I have my own social group, and the greatest rewards have come from working with family and my research team. The secret of lion society is mutual respect – there’s no real dominance hierarchy between the females or within most male coalitions – which seems the best way to collaborate with the people in my life.”  

The hunters may be liars, but he has little truck either with the religious fervour and sentimentality of the animal lovers. “Animal groups tend to [seem] religious. It feels like a theology. I get into conflict with everyone. I like fences. Animal lovers hate fences. I tell hunters, ‘you guys lie’. There are two sides to every argument and both sides are right on certain points.” 

The Cecil episode was instructive because, as a scientist, he finds the whole idea of naming lions bizarre. “There are lots of Cecils out there. Just last week one of my students reported a spearing of a lion by a Maasai. It had no name. Normally lions are called things like MH3T or lion LGB. 

“The Cecil story tells me that we as a species can only show empathy with individual organisms. The question is how do you fire up the same concerns for populations? It’s frustrating. 

“But Cecil did fire people up. It brought awareness and raised issues like should lions be on the endangered species list or should the EU ban trophies from certain African countries?” 

Cecil also helped open doors for Packer to lobby the US and EU for control of trophy imports. “Since Cecil, I have had auditions with local congresswomen. Frankly, the US Fish and Wildlife Service has been blase about lions. They have downplayed the damage that lion hunting inflicts. I have also asked the EU to take into account that Tanzania is corrupt and they should consider banning all trophies from there.” 

The root causes for the cataclysmic decline of wildlife in Africa, he says, are funding and population pressure. “Wildlife just does not have enough value. Cecil should not have been shot for $50,000. They should have charged $1m. Trophy hunting only provides a very small fraction of the money for conservation.” 

He favours the South African system of conservation, with wildlife effectively kept behind fences and strict regulation and demarcation of land. It may feel controlled and overmanaged, but it works, he says – and people do not get killed. 

“People are not going to magically stop killing lions. You can’t expect communities to accept lots of people being killed each year by lions.” 

The wider solution, he says, is for the world to recognise that the great African wildlife reserves are true world heritage sites and that their protection should be paid out of global funds.  

Cecil the lion: case against hunt leader should be thrown out, court told  

Lawyers for Theo Bronkhorst argue circumstances surrounding death of famous 13-year-old big cat do not constitute a chargeable offence  

“They are world treasures yet Unesco gives no money – there’s no revenue at all. Photo tourism is not enough. If you go to Yosemite you will be charged a nominal entry fee. That does not cover costs, but you’re paying for Yosemite with your taxes. The west has the tax base to cover the costs but Africa has the poorest people and no revenue. 

“We cannot expect wildlife to pay its way. I am now goading people to engage organisations like Unesco and the World Bank to recognise that if we are to keep the [wildlife], the global community must pay for them. That is my crusade. A lot of people have been duped into thinking that just by being a tourist or a hunter, it is enough. It’s not. 

“If the giga-bucks do not come, then there is no hope. I have resigned myself to the fact that in 50 years, the only places in Africa that will be worth going to [for wildlife] will be Botswana, Namibia and South Africa. All the rest will be gone.”

Tread lightly on the Earth

info@jvbigcats.co.za
Copyright 2007 @jvbigcats  All rights reserved


Newsletters


Newsletter 145
20/05/17
King Corbett

Newsletter 144
08/05/17
Hunting versus Non Hunting

Newsletter 143
14/03/17
If it Pays, it Stays

Newsletters 142
14/02/17
Best Photographs at
Tiger Canyons

Newsletters 141
16/01/17
Lady Hunters

Newsletter 140
10/12/16
Londolozi and Love

Newsletter 139
23/11/16
Life is Not Fair

Newsletter 138
17/11/16
The Trump Card

Newsletter 137
22/10/16
Most Admired People on the Planet

Newsletters 136
13/10/16
Captive vs Wild

Newsletter 135
08/10/16
To trade  or not To Trade

Newsletter 134
08/08/16
A Defining Moment

Newsletter 133
08/07/16
I Have Lost A Friend

Newsletter 132
13/05/16
The World is Changing

Newsletter 131
08/04/16
Icon Cats

Newsletter 130
31/03/16
Sylvester the Lion

Newsletter 129
22/03/16
An Open Letter to Head United Nations

Newsletter 128
15/03/16
An Open Letter to Carte Blanche

Newsletter 127
28/11/15
Satellite Tracking

Newsletter 126
12/11/15
Lightning strikes 3 times

Newsletter 125
28/10/15
The Break Out

Newsletter 124
05/10/15
Bad Tigers

Newsletter 123
01/10/15
Tiger Boy's Journey

Newsletter 122
13/09/15
Give it a Name

Newsletter 121
10/09/15
Driven Hunts

Newsletter 120
01/09/15
Creative Conservation

Newsletter 119
12/08/15
Sariska from birth till death

Newsletter 118
11/08/15
Real Hunters

Newsletter 117
07/08/15
An Open Letter to the President: Operation Wild Lion

Newsletter 116
03/08/15
An Open Letter to Theo Bronkhorst

Newsletter 115
28/07/15
Cruel Nations

Newsletter 114
08/07/15
Subspecies or no subspecies

Newsletter 113
11/06/15
Tigers Moving Forward

Newsletter 112
13/04/15
Between a Rock and a Hard Place

Newsletter 111
26/03/15
Don't Shoot the Messenger

Newsletter 110
22/03/15
The Hunters

Newsletter 109
09/03/15
Gaia or God?

Newsletter 108
26/02/15
The Healing Power of Cats

Newsletter 107
18/02/15
Goddess Gaia

Newsletter 106
03/02/15
Ambassador Cats

Newsletter 105
24/01/15
Blondes have more fun

Invitation
09/01/15
Gaining ground for tigers

Newsletter 103
14/12/14
Tibo's Dilemma

Newsletter 102
05/12/14
Wilderness Man

Newsletter 101
25/11/14
Sariska fathers cubs with white Tigress Tibo

Newsletter 100
20/11/14
Cheetah Survival

Newsletter 99
30/09/14
Extract from JV's speech on Corbett's Freedom Day

Newsletter 98
15/08/14
The Power of the Picture

Newsletter 97
18/07/14
Tiger Corbett's Release

Newsletter 96
11/07/14
Corbett's Journey

Newsletter 95
18/06/14
Bush School: Where are they now?

Newsletter 94
12/05/14
Open letter to Jani Allen: Oscar Pistorius

Newsletter 93
07/05/14
John Varty interview with Sizie Modise

Newsletter 92
20/04/14
Marion's Big Cat Safari

Newsletter 91
24/02/14
Full energy flow

Newsletter 90
10/02/14
Investing in wild tigers

Newsletter 89
05/02/14
Where are the Champions?

Newsletter 88
27/01/14
Managing the Genes

Newsletter 87
16/01/14
Capture the Moment

Newsletter 86
07/12/13
The Princess Diana of Tigers - Julie:
 Sept 1999 - 5 Des 2013

Newsletter 85
26/11/13
The Communicators

Newsletter 84
26/11/13
A Letter to All Conservationists in SA 
Sparked by the whole Melissa Bachman Debacle
by Maxine Gaines

Newsletter 83
16/11/13
Tell me what happened

Newsletter 82
04/11/13
Profit is the Name of Your Game

Newsletter 81
30/10/13

Big Cat Cub Safari


Newsletter 80
18/10/13
In the Jaws of the Tiger

Newsletter 79
11/10/13
Open letter to Vice President Cyril Ramaphosa about rhino crisis

Newsletter 78
06/10/13
Open letter to Min of Defense, South Africa about rhino crisis

Newsletter 77
30/09/13
Digital Photography

Newsletter 76
06/09/13
Zoochosis

Newsletter 75
20/07/13
Rhino Horn Trade - Response

Newsletter 74
09/07/13
Raw Power

Newsletter 73
02/07/13
The Evolution of the Tracker

Newsletter 72
02/07/13
An Open Letter to the Honourable Edna Molewa, Minister of Water Affairs and Environmental Affairs

Newsletter 71
06/06/13
Using flash or spotlight on cats at night

Newsletter 70
14/05/13
Mirror mirror on the wall, who has the best eyesight of them all?

Newsletter 69
12/04/13
Mirror, mirror on the wall, who is the fastest of them all?

Newsletter 68
25/03/13
Mirror, mirror on the wall, who is the best fighter of them all?

Newsletters 67
07/03/13
Wild Cheetah return to the Free State after 100 years

Newsletter 66
28/02/13
Seeking the genes

Newsletters 65
06/02/13
Corbett's Journey

Newsletters 64
22/01/13
In Search of a Mate

Newsletters 63
11/01/13
Rumble in the Jungle

Newsletters 62
30/10/12
Voronin Big Cat Safari Breaks All Records

Newsletters 61
09/12/12
A Journey to Nowhere

Newsletter 60
03/10/12
The John Hume Approach

Newsletter 59
28/09/12
Response to Rhino Horn Auction

Newsletters 58
24/09/12
A Letter to John Hume, SA biggest Rhino Breeder

Newsletters 57
05/09/12
Newsletters 56
01/08/12
Indian Government -
the wrong decision

Newsletter 55
11/07/12
What price must beauty pay?

Newsletter 54
21/04/12
Corbett's Freedom

Newsletter 53
15/04/12
Lethal injection or Freedom

Newsletters 52
04/04/12
The anatomy of an aggressive tiger

Newsletters 51
14/02/12
Majestic, breathtaking pictures

Newsletters 50
04/11/11
Tigress Calendar

Newsletters 49
19/11/11

Let your pictures do the talking

Newsletters 48
26/09/11

Rhino Wars

Newsletters 47
06/09/11
A Letter to the President

Newsletters 46
08/08/11
The Body Parts Scam

Newsletters 45
11/07/11
Tiger Subspecies

Newsletters 43
01/05/11
Your future and the Tiger

Newsletter 42
08/05/11
Talk to Me

Newsletter 41
26/01/11
Gaian Reminder

Newsletter 40
18/11/10
Ron's Journey

Newsletter 39
20/10/10
"Descreprimate"

Newsletter 38
06/09/10
Beauty comes at a price

Newsletter 37
18/08/10

The Light Has Gone Out


Newsletter 36
08/07/10
The Beautiful Game

Newsletter 35
05/07/10
The Ethics of
Tiger Green Hunting

Newsletter 34
21/06/10
Tiger Hunt

Newsletter 33
26/05/10
The Year of the Tiger

Newsletter 32
11/02/10

Riding the Tiger


Newsletter 31
24/01/10

Runti's Journey


Newsletter 30
12/01/10

To intervene or not to intervene -
that is the question...

Newsletter 29
07/12/09

Lion - Tiger - Human Communication


Newsletter 28
12/11/09

Emotional humans, emotional cats


Newsletter 27
03/11/09

Julie gives birth to 5 tiger cubs


Newsletter 26
24/09/09

International Tiger Day


Newsletter 25
17/08/09

To all Photographers


Newsletter 24
16/07/09

A Shot in Anger


Newsletter 22
24/04/09


Newsletter 21
24/03/09


Newsletter 19
14/01/09

Tiger Birth
at Tiger Canyons


Newsletter 16
10/10/08

Tiger Courting


Newsletter 11
29/01/08

Privatizing the Tiger


Newsletter 9
27/10/07

Newsletter 8
28/09/07

Newsletter 7
14/09/07

Water Cats


Newsletter 6
14/08/07

Tiger Intelligence


Newsletter 5
16/05/07

Tiger language
Tiger Boma


Newsletter 3
09/03/07

Interspecies communication


Newsletter 2
06/02/07

Cub relocation


Londolozi
Newsletters

Death of a Legend
17/08/09


Newsletter 20
10/02/09

Newsletter 15
17/08/08

Painted Wolves


Newsletter 13
11/04/08

Response to Elephant Trust
by Daryl Balfour


Newsletter 12
09/04/08

Elephant Trust